Haghia Sophia vs Basilica San Marco

Haghia Sophia, built to proclaim the might and majesty of the Eastern Roman Empire, dwarfs Venice’s Basilica San Marco in age, scale, and artistic achievement

ABOVE Hordes of tourists – and pigeons – outside Basilica San Marco, Venice, Italy
ABOVE Hordes of tourists – and pigeons – outside Basilica San Marco, Venice, Italy

NEED TO KNOW

LOCATION Haghia Sophia is in the district of Sultanahmet, in the heart of Old Istanbul, northwestern Turkey

DATE OF CONSTRUCTION AD 532–7

VISITORS PER YEAR Around 2.2 million

For nearly 1,000 years, Haghia Sophia was thought to be the most glorious church in Christendom.

Filled with treasures and decked out in gold, marble, semi-precious stones, and sumptuous mosaics, the church unashamedly showed off the status of Constantinople, the capital of the Byzantine Empire. When its founder, the Emperor Justinian, saw the church completed for the first time, he compared it to King Solomon’s splendid First Temple in Jerusalem, built 1,500 years earlier, exclaiming: “Oh Solomon, I have outdone you!” Haghia Sophia has served different purposes over the centuries: it was converted into a mosque by Sultan Mehmet the Conqueror following his capture of Constantinople in 1453, and became a museum under Atatürk in 1935. Despite these incarnations, the building remains Istanbul’s most iconic monument and one of the great religio-historic wonders of the world. Venice’s better-known Byzantine treasure, Basilica San Marco, might attract more visitors, but when it comes to atmosphere and architectural splendor, Haghia Sophia wins hands down.

The building’s spectacular, soaring dome and four graceful minarets dominate the city skyline, and enclose one of the largest interiors in the world. Stepping inside this majestic building can be rather an overwhelming experience. As you leave behind the swirling dust, street smells, and din of traffic and traders in Sultanahmet, you enter an extraordinary, vast sanctuary of diffused light, coolness, and peace.

Though much of the original material used to decorate Haghia Sophia has been looted over the centuries, many treasures remain. Don’t miss the dazzling 9th-century wall and floor mosaics, the 18th-century Sultan’s Loge, which allowed Sultan Ahmet III to pray unseen, and the impressive work of the master-calligrapher Mustafa İzzet Efendi, seen on the roundels that sit at the base of the dome. Also found here is the Weeping Column, which, legend has it, once belonged to St. Gregory the Miracle Worker, and which many people believe still retains powers of healing. This majestic building, which has withstood earthquakes and wars, is an enduring tribute to Byzantine art and one of the finest surviving buildings of antiquity.

FORGET SAN MARCO?

THE BUILD-UP This awesome 11th-century basilica, designed as the final resting place of St Mark the Evangelist, is one of the world’s most lavishly decorated churches. Among its many treasures are the saint’s tomb itself, the Byzantine mosaics adorning the ceilings, the Pala d’Oro altar screen, which has over 2,000 enameled panels studded with precious stones, and the San Marco Museum.

THE LETDOWN Basilica San Marco, the third church to be constructed on this site, postdates Haghia Sophia by 500 years. Disappointingly, many of its famous treasures are not the original church decorations, but were looted from other buildings around the world. San Marco is also one of the most visited sights in Europe, and the crowds here are enormous, so don’t come for peace and quiet.

GOING ANYWAY? If a visit to San Marco is still a must-do for you, try to come outside the main European holidays and avoid the hotter months, when Venice’s lagoon can reek. Arriving early in the morning will give you a head start on the cruise-ship and guided-tour groups.

PRACTICAL INFORMATION

Getting There and Around

Istanbul’s main airport, Ataturk International Airport, lies 15 miles (24 km) west of Sultanahmet.

Local trains, trams, airport buses, and taxis connect the airport with Sultanahmet.

Where to Eat

Istanbul boasts one of the best dining scenes in the world.

Restaurants, bistros, taverns, cafés, fast-food stalls, and food and spice markets are found everywhere here. For atmosphere and authenticity, follow the locals to the meyhanes (taverns) in Nevizade Sokak, one of Beyoğlu’s narrow streets, where you’ll find fresh fish and mouth-watering meze aplenty. If you’re looking for a restaurant with a view, head for Hamdi Et Lokantası, which has been an Istanbul institution since the 1970s.

Where to Stay

The famous Four Seasons Hotel Istanbul is hard to beat for its central location in Sultanahmet and luxurious interiors. The service here is also renowned.

When to Go

Spring (Apr–May) and fall (Sep–Oct) are the most pleasant times weather- and crowd-wise.

Budget per Day for Two

From US$175 depending on your choice of hotel and restaurants, and including transportation.

3 more religious monuments to rival basilica san marco

ST CATHERINE’S MONASTERY, MOUNT SINAI, EGYPT Dating from the 6th century, St Catherine’s is one of the oldest functioning monasteries in the world. It is set spectacularly at the foot of Mount Sinai, where Moses is said to have received the Ten Commandments, and contains a priceless collection of religious art, icons, and manuscripts.

MOUNT ATHOS, MACEDONIA, NORTHERN GREECE The semi-autonomous monastic state of Mount Athos has changed very little since Byzantine days. Its 2,000 monks continue their 1,000-year-old tradition of study and prayer, and no female – human or animal – is permitted entry. The only access is by boat.

RAVENNA’S BYZANTINE CHURCHES, ITALY Ravenna, once the western capital of the Byzantine Empire, is home to a number of beautiful churches dating from the 5th to the 7th centuries.

These churches are famous for their stunning mosaics, which are considered among the finest in Western art.

Leave a Comment