Melbourne Arts Festival vs the Edinburgh Fringe Festival

The Melbourne International Arts Festival can rival the artistic quality and cultural variety of the Edinburgh Fringe Festival – but without the crowds or the struggle for top tickets

ABOVE Crowds thronging the streets of Edinburgh city center during The Fringe Festival
ABOVE Crowds thronging the streets of Edinburgh city center during The Fringe Festival


LOCATION Melbourne is on Australia’s southeast coast, 650 miles (1,040 km) from the national capital, Canberra WHEN The festival runs for 17 days every October


Around 475,000


67°F (19°C) in October

The Melbourne International Arts Festival is Australia’s foremost celebration of global performing and visual arts. Established in 1986 as a sister festival to the Festival dei Due Mondi in Spoleto, Italy (see pp268–9), and the Spoleto Festival USA, in Charleston, South Carolina (whose “two worlds” are those of European and American culture), the festival was first known as the Spoleto Festival Melbourne but took on its current name in 2003. Today, it is renowned for premiering and promoting some of the best national and international artistes and companies. Unlike the sprawling, all-embracing Edinburgh Fringe, with its hit-and-miss aesthetic, everything here – no matter how avant-garde or experimental – is staged on the merit of its quality.

The Melbourne Festival offers its visitors a multicultural smorgasbord of dance, theater, opera, music, visual arts, multimedia, and outdoor events. Each year boasts around 60 to 80 events held in a host of inner-city venues, including the flagship Arts Centre, home to the Playhouse and State Theatres, nestled next to the Yarra River and topped by Melbourne’s now-iconic spire; The Famous Spiegeltent, a European Mirror Tent billed as “the ultimate cabaret and music salon,” which is pitched in the Arts Centre forecourt for the duration; and the National Gallery of Victoria, with its striking “water wall” and stained-glass ceiling.

Federation Square acts as the central point of the festivities, and the opening and closing parties are held in this colorful open-plan space. Both events celebrate the artists, the audiences, and the multicultural city of Melbourne itself. Melburnians have long prided themselves on being Australia’s cultural ambassadors: the accent is considered more refined; the main thoroughfare, Collins Street, has a leafy “Paris End”; and a plethora of theaters and galleries ensures a healthy arts diet all year.

The Melbourne Festival boosts this much-vaunted reputation with 17 days of ticketed and free events, most of them programmed by a high-profile artistic director on a three- or four-year contract.

Previous programs have included recitals from the classical Schönberg Ensemble; performances by the Merce Cunningham Dance Company; a photography exhibition and concert by the “Godmother of Punk,” artist and musician Patti Smith, as well as a collaborative event with the composer Philip Glass; and a performance by the all-star indigenous Australian collective, the Black Arm Band. As a background to the live shows, an In Conversation discussion series offers insights into the thoughts of many extraordinary artistes. There are also workshops in dance, theater and music, lectures, and school and family events. With entertainment for night owls at the Beck’s Bar, Artist Bar, and The Famous Spiegeltent, the Melbourne Festival is as inclusive as it is inspiring.


THE BUILD-UP The Edinburgh Fringe Festival is officially the largest arts festival in the world. For three hectic weeks each August, “The Fringe,” as it is known, encompasses over 30,000 performances by hundreds of groups, spanning theater, stand-up, music, dance and children’s entertainment in around 250 venues.

THE LETDOWN Huge crowds mill along Edinburgh’s Royal Mile to watch street performers, buy tickets from the Fringe Shop, and amass flyers for shows. Well-reviewed shows sell out very early, leaving a choice of less-than-satisfactory alternatives: with no selection and approval process, quality varies widely.

GOING ANYWAY? Take time out to relax on a café terrace, stroll along the Water of Leith Walkway, or visit the city’s spectacular castle. On the second Sunday in August, head to the large green expanse of the Meadows for the carnivalesque Fringe Sunday, a free showcase of events.


Getting There and Around

Most major international airlines fly to Melbourne’s Tullamarine Airport, 14 miles (22 km) from the city center. Take a taxi or the 24-hour Skybus into Melbourne.

The city center is a neat grid on the Yarra River, compact but with good public transportation too.

Where to Eat

For exceptional tapas visit MoVida; revisit the French classics at Bistro Guillaume; or indulge in some haute cuisine at Vue de Monde. For modern Australian food, Rockpool

Bar & Grill is hard to beat.

Where to Stay

The Grand Hyatt is on stylish Collins St; the central Hotel Lindrum has a club-like ambience; Crown Promenade on Southbank is smart and affordable.

Budget per Day for Two

US$250, including accommodations, meals, and public transportation.

Leave a Comment